Great Season, Lousy Postseason: Braves lose NLDS to Phillies
[Read how the Atlanta Braves got to the postseason here.]
There was a new Wild Card round this season. The old format of a one-game playoff was ditched for a new best of three game series played in the higher ranked team's stadium. The New York Mets would host the San Diego Padres while the NL Central champion St. Louis Cardinals played at home against the Philadelphia Phillies. Meanwhile, the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Atlanta Braves got a few days off for finishing with the top records in the National League.
I mapped out my ideal postseason situation for my baseball friend, Jerry. The Mets would beat the Padres and then go on to beat the Dodgers – since they won the season series against the 111 – 51 juggernaut from LA. Meanwhile, the Phillies would defeat the Cardinals – a team Atlanta had a bad postseason history against. Then the Braves would best the Phillies and end up winning over the Mets in the NLCS for another trip to the World Series. Oh, and someone would beat the Yankees – another team the Braves had trouble with historically – over in the American League. After eliminating the Mets we would play whoever and win back-to-back World Series Championships for the first time since the Yankees did it 1998 – 2000.
Of course, it didn't turn out exactly that way. The Mets lost to Padres. So the weaker team would go on to probably lose to LA. But the Phillies won out over the Cardinals, so at least we would play the team I preferred in the NLDS. Braves ace Max Fried started the best of five game series in Atlanta. I felt pretty confident and the overall consensus was that Atlanta would win the series.
But Fried sucked. In less the four innings he gave up eight hits, six runs (four earned), and only struck out two. The Braves bullpen pretty much shut the Phillies down afterwards. Philadelphia outhit Atlanta 12 – 9. The Braves dropped Game One 7 – 6. Ronald Acuna, Jr. looked sharp with three hits. Travis d'Arnaud and Matt Olson hit big homers but Dansby Swanson struck out in all four at-bats and Austin Riley struck out three times. We could not win without Swanson and Riley and without Fried pitching up to his ability.
One bad consequence of dropping Game One was that we had our “ace” starter going against Philadelphia's #3 starter in their rotation. It was a match-up where we theoretically should have out-pitched them. But it didn't work out for the Braves. That's baseball, as Jerry says. Now their ace was going against our #2 starter. That isn't as big a difference usually as #1 against #3, however.
I was still confident going into Game Two. Sure, we were in a hole. Now we had to win three out of the next four games but we could do it. With decent starting pitching we would have taken the first game. Kyle Wright would try to give us what we needed the next afternoon in Atlanta. Both Wright and Zack Wheeler performed in top-notch fashion. Then both bullpens pitched well. There were only seven hits and three walks total in the game. Great fielding plays were featured by each side. It was a fun old style game to watch.
The Braves won 3 – 0 on three run-scoring singles with two-out off Wheeler in the sixth inning. We got a little lucky on one of them. But I'll usually take luck when it comes our way. Olson is a bullet just off the glove of the diving first baseman. He looked good at the plate so far in the series Riley hit a big-swing dinker that dribbled out between third base and the mound. That was just the way the ball bounces. Our luck, which was a good sign really. You need both talent and luck in the postseason. d'Arnaud's single up the middle was a classic example of going with the pitch, an old style clutch player.
Fried wonked-out in Game One or we would be up 2 – 0. We got a little lucky with that 3-run 2-out rally but it was old style baseball off their ace, which was fun to see. In Game One the Phillies drove-in runs with bunts and sac flies. Not one home run. I hated it but I have to admit it is baseball I recognize. Baseball was like that when I was younger.
I really enjoyed the first two games. Now I was hoping for a split in Philadelphia. I knew those Philly fans were going to be electrified for their first home game after four postseason road games (winning three of them). Sweeping the Cards. They had some momentum and they were headed home. I hoped the real Charlie Morton showed up.
I was concerned about our line-up though. Swanson and Riley or Eddie Rosario or somebody needed to help Acuna, Olson, and d'Arnaud drive in runs. Meanwhile, Spencer Strider was our ace in the hole (if he was really healthy enough). He owned the Phillies in 2022 going 4 – 0 with a stellar 1.27 ERA. Yeah, I still felt we would still take the series. Now all we had to do was win two out of three.
Surprise! Snitker decided to start Strider in Game Three. I was excited and was sure, if healthy, the rookie would continue to own Philadelphia. But that's not what happened. Strider sucked. He didn't survive the third inning in which the Phillies scored six runs. They went on to whip Atlanta 9 – 1. The Braves bats looked anemic again. Olson and Riley went hitless. Riley was batting a pathetic .083 for the NLDS. Desperate for some optimism, I thought back to September 23, when we lost to Philadelphia by the same score. We came back to win two in row against them. Could we do it again?
We had to. We were facing elimination. It was up to Charlie Morton and the Braves bats had to get going. We needed to win two games in a row if we were going to make it to the NLCS for a chance to return to the World Series. But I knew all to well you can't win two games at once. We had to win Game Four first. We had to do it in Philadelphia where the fans were going bonkers and all the momentum was against us.
Philadelphia beat us 8 – 3. Morton lasted only two innings. Acuna had no hits. Swanson had no hits. Riley had no hits. Our rookie of the year center fielder (Michael Harris II) had no hits. There was no spark in this team. The whole series I never once saw the spark that we had this time last season. It makes last season more special. The Atlanta Braves are World Series Champions. But I won't get to say that in a couple of weeks.
It was a blah series and the Phillies definitely deserved to win. They dominated us. But as bad as that hurts, do I really have reason to complain? We have the two best rookies in the league. A power hitter (Harris) and a power starter (Strider). We have Fried who, despite sucking in Game One, is a true ace with a great future. Wright, who pitched our only win in the NLDS, came into his own this season. He put himself in the 20-win club, which is an elite statistic these days.
Most of these guys are coming back next year. Probably not Swanson, though. Swanson will likely become the 2023 version of what Freddie Freeman was in 2022. Swanson's free agency will demand an amount that we might could spend in other ways. But we'll see.
And we have Brian Snitker. Don't quit with Snit. I find myself almost always agreeing with his decisions. He is great at making adjustments until a team's chemistry levels up to its talent. That is the key to winning. The Braves won 101 ballgames in 2022, the most since they won the same number back in 2003. As a Braves fan, that alone should make me smile. It was an outstanding season followed by a disappointing postseason, which is classic Atlanta Braves stuff. Despite winning the World Series, Atlanta is still haunted by a long tradition of underachieving in the postseason.
Still, I am confident for our future. This team has a dynasty going within its own division. It needs a few more series wins in the postseason to become a true baseball dynasty (similar to what it was in the 1990s). I think we will be back next year, possibly stronger than ever before. And when you think of things that way and I pause to feel how that feels in a broader sense, my baseball life is so good.
The Braves were eliminated on the same day that the San Diego Padres shockingly eliminated the Los Angeles Dodgers. Freddie Freeman struck out swinging to end the series before a raucous San Diego crowd. For the first time in three seasons the Braves won't face the Dodgers in the NLCS. Over in the junior circuit, the Houston Astros won an astonishing 18-inning game with a walk-off home run. The Cleveland Guardians (formerly Indians) were up 2 -1 in their series against the New York Yankees. I was rooting for the Guardians, of course.
There were other reasons for appreciating the 2022 season besides the Braves 101 wins. Albert Pujols crossed the 700-homer run mark and join the elite company of Babe Ruth and Hank Aaron. Bonds made it too, on steroids. But the greatest personal accomplishment had to be Aaron Judge of the Yankees surpassing Roger Maris's single-season home run record in the AL. He hit 62, which is a superhuman accomplishment without the use of performance enhancing drugs. Only eight other players in MLB history have hit 60 or more home runs in a season. It is remarkable to be alive and appreciate all these rare things.
The highlight of the season for me personally has to be the sweep of the Mets at home earlier this month. That was a fun and satisfying three games. It took the Braves all season to pass the Mets. It was an outstanding fight to the finish to win the division and that sweep did it with authority. We have a great team and a great manager. These next few years should continue to deliver fun for Braves fans.
Comments